The National Football League’s 58^th Annual Super Bowl ended with a winning team and fans who might be recovering from a tough season. Whether you’re an athlete or a fan watching sporting events in person or at home, the competitive nature of sports can be both exhilarating and heart-wrenching. However, what happens when the passion felt for the game triggers emotions such as sadness or depression? In this interview with Magellan Federal’s Performance Coaching Manager Meg Helf, M.S., CMPC®, we explore the concept known as “sports fan depression.”

What is Sports Fan Depression and is it a real diagnosis?

Meg Helf: Although Sports Fan Depression is not an official diagnosis in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5-TR), many of us are all too familiar with the emotional rollercoaster that comes along with being a fan. Reactions to any number of life events can linger and develop into diagnosable depression, prolonged grief disorder, or an adjustment disorder with depressed mood. Just as we experience grief with the loss of a relationship or a loved one, a job or an opportunity, we may experience grief at the end of a season or when our favorite team comes up short.

For sports fans, acute grief is that initial intense feeling after a loss takes place. This may manifest in a range of complex feelings such as sadness, anger, frustration, and disappointment, which often isn’t discussed in the context of sport. When this grief is experienced for extended periods of time and starts to impact our daily functioning (e.g., work, eating habits, sleep, relationships), we might be experiencing what many call Sports Fan Depression.

What is it about sports that can trigger this feeling?

Helf: There are several reasons that sports can trigger these feelings. Fans make emotional, psychological, physical, and sometimes financial investments in their teams. There are a plethora of ways that sports can impact our wellbeing: sports can be integral to one’s identity, sports can drive our daily activities, and, sports have the ability to create communities and develop relationships.

The more someone identifies with their team the stronger they may feel loss about the outcome of the game or result of the season. These events can feel like a blow to our personal identity when we have a sense of pride and belonging. Despite superstitions and lucky shirts, socks, and routines, fans have a lack of influence and impact on the outcome of the game. This may set many up with unrealistic expectations and add a sense of helplessness. A player on the field has the ability to distinguish what went well, identify what they and the team need to develop, and maintain a future focused growth mindset regardless of the outcome. With less control, it is understandable that fans struggle with optimism because they cannot take any action to make the desired change.

For some, being a fan is a part-time (or full-time!) job. Between watching games, competing in fantasy leagues, and researching statistics, our daily lives are filled with something that we are passionate about. Similarly to how some marathon runners experience the “post-race blues,” when a season is over, we may feel a loss for all the time we invested and feel like a large part of our daily excitement and activities are missing. As the season comes to a close, that taste of the adrenaline, tension, energy and anticipation of each game fades and may leave us wanting.

Fans also rarely go it alone. Our favorite team has the ability to connect people, both friends and strangers alike. Fans connect across time zones for draft parties and engage in banter through fantasy leagues, spend hours tailgating before a game, and gather for watch parties. Families strengthen bonds, adorning newborns in gear and creating traditions. Strangers high-five. They hug. They share food, drinks and handwarmers. Even opposing fans engage in playful banter and share stories. Entire cities come together to support their team. We win together. We lose together. And when the season is over, we are losing these opportunities for such a meaningful part of life – connection to others.

How can someone identify if they suffer from this condition?

Helf: A couple of symptoms experienced with depression are diminished interest or pleasure in activities, depressed mood, significant unintentional weight gain or loss, insomnia or sleeping too much, fatigue or loss of energy, feelings of worthlessness or excessive guilt, and diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness. Prolonged grief symptoms are intense emotional pain, loss of identity, difficulty moving on with life, emotional numbness, feeling that life is meaningless, and intense loneliness.

Individuals should build self-awareness about the intensity and duration of their symptoms, and the impact they have on their daily lives. Tap into your thoughts. Are they pervasive? Is the loss of the game bleeding over to other areas of your life? Be purposeful with your next steps and be on the alert for destructive or non-productive patterns that may not help you (e.g., alcohol, adrenaline/thrill seeking, substance abuse, risk-taking).

What are steps someone should take if they believe they have Sports Fan Depression?

Helf:

• Make some intentional time to mourn the loss and build self-awareness of when intrusive thoughts creep in so you can shift to more productive, optimistic style thinking.
• Expand your identity – who are you outside of being a loyal, avid fan?
• Develop and maintain healthy habits – make time to move your body, prioritize healthy eating, hydration, and sleep. These habits are always crucial, but especially helpful for individuals who are struggling.
• Cultivate connections with others – reconnect with your fellow fans in a different context and develop new communities. Diversify your portfolio on interests and discover activities that generate positive emotions and engagement.
• Unplug from your fandom. Clear your head and provide an opportunity to get a little emotional distance from the season. Taking time for yourself will sow benefits for you and those around you. If the post-season funk stays around for longer than 2-4 weeks, find a professional to talk to or take a depression screen.

It’s important to understand that it is perfectly natural to have emotional highs and lows when you are so connected and invested with a specific sports team. Just because you experience some grief, sadness, or disappointment does not mean you have depression. It is typical to have reactions when any season changes and normal to reset your compass.

Perhaps consider why you watch sports in the first place. Is it the appreciation of athletic prowess? The comradery and connection with others? Pride in your town? Understanding what is most important to you can help you squeeze every ounce of enjoyment and excitement out of the game, while arming you with strategies to cultivate your wellbeing.

For more information on depression screenings and tips on wellness, please check out: The Journey to Wellness: Do I need a Depression Screening?

And remember…there is always next season!

---

Resources

Online screens and helplines: 

• Anxiety & Depression Association of America: (1)
• The Reach Institute (2)
• Mental Health America (16)
• Veteran’s Administration (17)
• SAMHSA National Helpline: 1-800-662-4357
• NAMI Helpline: 1-800-950-6264

 

Mental health disorders are among the costliest health concerns for employers in the United States. According to the National Institute of Mental Health, nearly one in five adults live with a mental illness. Depression and anxiety are among the most common mental health disorders but often go undiagnosed and untreated.¹

Many factors may contribute to mental health issues, including traumatic or abusive life experiences, biology, and family history of mental health problems. Unfortunately, social stigma and fear of discrimination prevent many people from seeking help.

Employee mental health impacts the bottom line

Poor mental health and stress can negatively affect employee job performance, productivity and relationships. In addition, as physical health is inextricably linked to mental health, many people with mental health disorders are at high risk for chronic physical conditions such as heart disease, diabetes and respiratory illnesses.²

The reverse is also true; physical illness, such as cardiovascular disease, may cause or worsen mental health issues, particularly symptoms of depression.³ Healthcare costs to treat people with both mental and physical disorders can easily be two to three times higher than for people without co-occurring illnesses.⁴

Employers have a unique opportunity to improve employee mental health

Investing in mental health treatment in general has proven to be cost-effective. Employers can reduce health care costs for their businesses and their employees by addressing mental health issues in the workplace. Many evidence-based treatments can save $2 to $4 for every dollar invested in prevention and early intervention.⁵ An effective approach is not one-size-fits-all but takes into consideration generational differences and employee diversity.

A recent study published in the Harvard Business Review called “People want their employers to talk about mental health” indicated that millennials (the cohort of people born between 1981 to 1996) were three times more likely to experience anxiety than baby boomers.⁶ Gen Zers (those born between 1997 to 2012) report even higher rates of anxiety and depression. Millennials and Gen Z employees are the largest demographic in the workforce, and those who took part in the survey indicated an expectation that mental health be addressed in the workplace openly and without stigma.

Develop a customized approach to promoting mental health resources

The Harvard Business Review study recommends a multi-faceted approach that includes a more accepting culture starting from the top, with training and support, as well as clear information about employee resources such as availability of mental health benefits, wellness programs and employee assistance programs.

Employers should be cognizant of where their different employee groups seek information and use those channels (whether it’s the intranet, staff meetings, one-on-one meetings, employee resource groups, digital signs and posters, instant messaging platforms, or other social media venues) to provide needed information. Virtual mental health counseling and the availability of mental health apps offer convenient and mobile-friendly emotional support, particularly for younger employee groups accustomed to using their smart phones for everything from texting to shopping.

Dislodging stigma and experimenting with different communications channels to meet the needs of a diverse workforce can be challenging for human resources departments and managers. But the end result will be worth the effort: a healthier work environment that supports healthier employees and enhanced productivity.

Learn more about how your organization can benefit from an EAP solution.

 

1 “Facts & Statistics.” Anxiety and Depression Association of America, ADAA, https://adaa.org/about-adaa/press-room/facts-statistics.

2 “Chronic Illness & Mental Health.” National Institute of Mental Health, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/chronic-illness-mental-health/index.shtml.

3 “Chronic Illness & Mental Health.” National Institute of Mental Health, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/chronic-illness-mental-health/index.shtml.4 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2748662?

5 Lerner D, Lyson M, Sandberg E, & Rogers W.H. (2018). The High Cost of Mental Disorders- Facts for

Employers. Retrieved from https://onemindinitiative.org/at-work/the-business-case/

6 Greenwood, Kelly, Bapa, Vivek, Maughan, Mike (2019). Research: People want their employers to talk about mental health. Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2019/10/research-people-want-their-employers-to-talk-about-mental-health